17 August 2013

Did Brother Felix Y. Manalo Died Like Judas Iscariot?


Answering Lies Against Brother Felix Y. Manalo:
"Felix Manalo Died Like Judas Iscariot"
by The Splendor Of The Church blog



DID BROTHER FELIX Y. MANALO DIED LIKE JUDAS ISCARIOT?



AN article in the blog titled “The Splendor of the Church” administered by a Catholic priest, Abe arganiosa, posted an article titled “Felix Manalo Died Like Judas Iscariot”. This article shows how desperate the Catholic Defenders in refuting the biblical fact that Brother Felix Y. Manalo is indeed God’s messenger in these last days.

Comparing the death of Brother Felix Y. Manalo with Judas Iscariot, their argument goes like this: “Felix Manalo died like Judas, and the latter was a traitor and an evil man, thus Felix Manalo is also a traitor and an evil man like Judas.”

THE ARGUMENT IS INDEED FALLACIOUS FOR TWO REASONS:

(1) IT’S A “NON-SEQUITOR” (“IT DOESN’T FOLLOW”). The coincidence or the similarity of the death of a certain person to the death of an evil man, a traitor or a criminal, doesn’t make that person also an evil man, a traitor or a criminal.

Many criminals died of sickness, does that make a person that died of sickness also a criminal? There are traitors that died of old age, does that make a person died of old age a traitor?

The Lord Jesus Christ Himself died the same manner as the two criminals at His left side and right side – they were also crucified like the Lord Jesus. Does that make Him also a criminal?


(2) THE CATHOLIC EFENDERS ARE LYING IN SAYING THAT BROTHER FELIX Y. MANALO DIED LIKE JUDAS ISCARIOT.”

Yes, the Catholic Defenders are lying in claiming that Brother Felix Y. Manalo died like Judas Iscariot.


(a) Catholic Defenders admit that Brother Felix Y. Manalo died of “INTESTINAL PROBLEM”:

“A friend shared to me this e-mail coming from an anonymous Catholic apologist who sent us the materials against Felix Manalo which I posted earlier. Now he is saying that Manalo died like Judas the Traitor as narrated in the Acts of the Apostles. Actually, I already heard this accusation against Manalo but I lost the documentation from the Pasugo. Now this brother gave us the date of the Pasugo. This is confirmed by the Wikipedia that indeed the self-proclaimed ‘angel’ DIED OF INTESTINAL PROBLEM — POOR ANGEL!” (from the Splendor Of The Church blog, emphasis mine)

IF BROTHER FELIX Y. MANALO DIED OF INTESTINAL PROBLEM AS ADMITTED BY CATHOLIC DEFENDERS, DOES THAT MEAN THAT JUDAS ALSO DIED OF “INTESTINAL PROBLEM”? We know that Judas did not.


(b) The Wikipedia that the Catholic Defenders quoted says that Brother Felix Y. Manalo died of “INTESTINAL DISEASE”:

“Manalo was married to Tomasa Sereneo, with whom he had a child who died in infancy. Tomasa herself was afflicted with tuberculosis and died as well. He later married Honorata de Guzman, a fellow former Adventist. Their fifth child, EraƱo G. Manalo, is now the present Executive Minister of the Iglesia ni Cristo, while his grandsonEduardo is deputy Executive Minister. Felix Manalo was afflicted with an intestinal disease and died on April 12, 1963.” (From Wikipedia as quoted by The Splendor of the Church blog)

Brother Felix Y. Manalo died of “intestinal disease”. DID JUDAS ALSO DIED OF “INTESTINAL DISEASE”? Judas committed suicide.


(c) Comparing the statement of PASUGO with Acts 1:18 reveals that Brother Felix Y. Manalo did not died like Judas:

The “Splendor of the Church” blog quoted the statement written in the May-June 1986 issue of the PASUGO Magazine (the official magazine of the Iglesia Ni Cristo). This is what they quoted:

“It was only after many years later, in February 1963, that Manalo fell gravely ill. He was rushed to St. Lukes hospital in Quezon City where doctors decided to remove immediately “an intestinal obstruction”. Manalo rejected the surgery, saying, “Doctors can cure only those who are not yet to die, not those whose time has come.” By March 21, 1963, his incapacitation was total and he was transferred to Veterans Memorial Hospital. Doctors operated on him but failed to give him relief from pain.
“On April 2, the doctors worked on Manalo again to sew back part of his intestines which had burst and hemorrhaged. On April 11, they performed a third surgery on him. It proved to be the last.
“The following day, April 12, 1963, at 2:35 oclock in the morning, the brilliant, tireless and courageous Filipino religious leader who had brought the Iglesia ni Cristo to great heights of glory and prominence, breathed his last. He was 77 years old. It was his 49thyear as chief steward of the Church.”

The Catrholic Defenders even underlined the words “On April 2, the doctors worked on Manalo again to sew back part of his intestines which had burst and hemorrhaged. On April 11, they performed a third surgery on him. It proved to be the last.”

Now let us compare how Judas died as narrated by the Bible. This is what Acts 1:18 says as rendered by the Catholic English Bible called Douay-Rheims:

    
Acts 1:18 Douay-Rheims
And he indeed hath possessed a field of the reward of iniquity, and being hanged, burst asunder in the midst: and all his bowels gushed out.

This Catholic English Bible said that Judas “burst asunder in the midst: and all his bowels gushed out.” What does it mean that Judas burst asunder in the midst”? What the Douay-Rheims said that Judas “burst asunder in the midst”, explained by the New King James Version:

Acts 1:18 NKJV
“(Now this man purchased a field with the wages of iniquity; and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his entrails gushed out.”

New King James Version said that Judas “burst open in the middle.” How did Judas “burst open in the middle”?  

Acts 1:18 NIV
“(With the reward he got for his wickedness, Judas bought a field; there he fell headlong, his body burst open and all his intestines spilled out.”

New International Version said, “his body burst open.” The version called The Message explains this:

Acts 1:18-19 The Message
"As you know, he took the evil bribe money and bought a small farm. There he came to a bad end, rupturing his belly and spilling his guts. 1

Thus, how did Judas died? He committed suicide, hanging himself, but he fell headfast and his belly burst open and his intestine spilled out. WHAT BURST WAS JUDAS’ BELLY BECAUSE HE FELL TO THE GROUND WHEN HE HANGED HIMSELF, AND HIS INTESTINE SPILLED OUT.

However, how did Brother Felix Manalo died? He died of intestinal problem – there was an “intestinal obstruction” until his intestine burst and hemorrhaged, thus on April 11, the doctors performed a third surgery on him, but It proved to be the last.

HERE, IT IS CLEAR THAT CATHOLIC DEFENDERS LIED ON SAYING THAT BROTHER FELIX Y. MANALO DIED LIKE JUDAS ISCARIOT.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments submitted must be civil, remain on-topic and not violate any laws. We reserve the right to delete any comments which are abusive, inappropriate or not constructive to the discussion. Repeated violations are ground to be blocked from this blog.